In response to one of my recent posts, a short "teaser" article for a new line of free reed instruments by Don Rickert Design, my friend David Mills commented that he once proposed the idea of replacing the bellows of organ-type free reed instruments with a foot-powered air pump and was accused of simply reinventing the harmonium. I am sure that we will be similarly criticized. Anyway, David's much-appreciated comment inspired this short article. I hope that you find it thought-provoking at least entertaining. "Reinventing the wheel" (and similar phrases like "reinventing the harmonium" or "reinventing the violin") is an English metaphorical idiom of unknown origin. There are varying definitions; however, the fundamental idea is that to reinvent the wheel, metaphorically of course, is to waste one's time inventing something that has already been invented AND has been PERFECTED. In the corporate world, as well as academe, both of which I am intimately familiar, dreamers are often cut down in their tracks with the admonition from some arrogant fool and his or her sycophants: "Don't reinvent the wheel!" In addition demonstrating lack of imagination by use of a hackneyed cliche, the "Don't reinvent the wheel" admonition is usually inappropriately used, reflecting even more poorly on the admonisher. There is that pesky perfection criterion, you see. Unless one really knows that an existing contraption or idea that is supposedly being reinvented cannot be improved, the key criterion for legitimate use of the "Don't reinvent the wheel" phrase has NOT been met!... Read more →